Microfinance USA Conference Blog

Weekly Microfinance News & Announcements 2/17/2012

Posted: 2012-02-17 @ 9:42 AM EST

Obama’s SBA Budget: Doing Less With More

By Robb Mandelbaum, New York Times Microloan counseling would not fare as badly, but other programs that serve the most disadvantaged small businesses, like HubZones and outreach to Native …

Social entrepreneurs use startups to change the world

By VentureBeat With 50000 visitors to its website per day (higher than any other nonprofit with the exception of Wikipedia), Kiva is often cited as the premier success story in this space. Kiva’s President, Premel Shah, recently recognized as a young global leader by …

Who Needs to be Educated for Us to Achieve Financial Inclusion?

By Center for Financial Inclusion Maybe the first focus of financial education should not be at the client level. Maybe the appropriate starting point is for those of us employed by the microfinance industry to better understand our clients’ financial needs, capabilities, and aspirations.

Could Google Wallet be Google’s next failure?

By Marguerite Reardon, CNET (blog) On Friday, Google temporarily disabled the ability to set up new prepaid cards in its Google Wallet app after it was discovered that if someone lost his Google Wallet-enabled phone and the screen of the device wasn’t locked that someone finding the …

Starbucks’s Schultz to Expand Jobs Fund After Raising $2 Million

By Leslie Patton, Bloomberg Businessweek Josh Davis cofounder of Gelato Fiasco Inc in Brunswick Maine received a $140000 loan from Coastal Enterprises Inc through Create Jobs for USA to open a …

Kabbage Crunches UPS Shipping Data to Approve Small Business Loans

By Penny Crosman, American Banker “If you have a FICO score below 720, banks won’t look at you for a small business loan,” says Kathryn Petralia, co-founder and COO of Kabbage, a provider of working capital to small online merchants. “It’s horrible, perverted logic because small …

The Lessons of Microfinance History

By David Roodman, CGAP The chapter would tell stories, such as how Yunus came to devise his form of microcredit, how John Hatch came to village banking. And it would show statistics—how many borrowers and savers there are, in what countries they can be found.

Microfinance in Bangladesh: It’s Not What You Thought

By Elizabeth Rhyne, Huffington Post (blog) The model of microfinance in Bangladesh, as it originated at Grameen Bank, involved tiny loans to women with fixed terms and amounts, group liability, weekly meetings, forced payments into a group savings account, and a set of 16 social pledges chanted …

Weekly Microfinance News & Announcements 2/10/2012

Posted: 2012-02-10 @ 5:00 AM EST

What Digital Non-Profits Can Learn From Companies Like Google

By Daniel Atwood, Mashable Kiva: This is an early one, but one worth noting. Kiva created a digital platform to connect small-dollar funders with nascent social entrepreneurs. This let it scale its model in a way that would have been nearly impossible had it not put a …

A Bill to Improve USAID’s Interventions in Microfinance

By Microfinance Focus A new bi-partisan microfinance bill was introduced in the Senate of the United States in December last year to …

Accessing the Future: Beyond the Traditional Microfinance Space

By Camilla Nestor, Center for Financial Inclusion For questions about this series, write to Sonja E. Kelly, Fellow, Center for Financial Inclusion at ACCION International. In five years, how will the poor be accessing financial services? If we could step back in time to 2006 with the microfinance …

How Millennials Are Shaping the Future of Social Entrepreneurship and Technology

By Melissa Richer, Huffington Post It is a big social entrepreneurship trend, which Kiva made famous a few years ago. Now many social entrepreneurs have innovated on this concept. Solar Mosaic makes it possible for anyone to fund community solar installations in places like schools or …

Denver to Refocus Economic-Development Office on Helping Startups

By Steve Raabe, Denver Post Small-business loan recipients that succeed and grow could then become customers of lower-risk conventional loans from US Bank, Salem said. Other banks that have expressed initial support for the investment fund include Wells Fargo and FirstBank.

MICROFINANCE EVENT: Muhammad Yunus Documentary “Bonsai People”

By MicroCapital Summary of Event: Bonsai People is a 79-minute documentary on Dr Muhammad Yunus and his work in microcredit and social business. The movie was directed by independent filmmaker Holly Mosher and was released in 2010. Dr Yunus founded microfinance …

Yale Faculty Reflects on Realities of Microfinance

By Microfinance Focus In many places it’s very expensive to provide microcredit, so the interest rates that you have to charge in order to get the sustainable machine going end up negating a lot of the reasons why you even started doing it in the first place”, says Rodrigo …

Fast Talk: How A Former Google Exec Plans To Transform Loans

By David Zax, Fast Company “All data is credit data,” he says–and the insight is helping America’s “underbanked” legions. A few years ago, Douglas Merrill became convinced that good people were being denied credit, just because loaners weren’t sifting through enough data.

Programming Guides from FIELD for Student Groups and Startup MFIs

Posted: 2012-02-08 @ 12:20 PM EST

Are you involved in a startup microfinance organization in the United States? If so, take some time to read FIELD’s recent publications Marketing for Micro 101: Lessons from around the U.S. and Data That Works.

Why these publications?

In 1999, FIELD and the Aspen Institute published a case study on student-run microfinance organizations in the US and their role in the domestic microfinance industry. The study concluded that “…university-based initiatives contain promising assets and resources that could strengthen the domestic microenterprise field.”   Since then, FIELD has continued to support student microfinance groups in strengthening their programing. These publications, released in late 2011, are designed as a conceptual roadmap towards designing a well-targeted and effective microfinance program. Both handbooks are comprehensive enough to serve the same purpose for any small MFI looking to design or improve its programming.

Marketing for Microfinance 101

Marketing for Micro 101 opens with a succinct overview of the challenges of market penetration, one of the biggest obstacles for MFIs large and small. It describes the process of establishing a target market, and offers several helpful resources for market research.  It goes on to emphasize the importance of applying the lessons learned from the market research to a program’s design and offers several brief but pointed case studies of MFIs that have done just that with great results. Marketing for Microfinance offers an in-depth overview of several potential outreach strategies, including direct client outreach, indirect marketing through partner organizations, and channel development for targeted marketing.  For those looking for more in-depth marketing information the guide offers links to other FIELD resources on the topic. Marketing for Microfinance concludes by warning against some common pitfalls in client outreach, including choosing or managing your partners unwisely, and failing to be responsive to client your data and client feedback. This handbook is truly an excellent starting place for MFIs that want to learn how to target both their products and their marketing.

Data that Works

Data that Works tackles another of the most daunting challenges for any MFI: effective data collection. This vital step, which is so often overwhelming to MFIs with limited human resource and training capacities, is broken down into a few important conceptual steps:

Define your information needs: Data That Works encourages readers to be realistic both about their information needs, and their capacity to collect and manage data. It breaks down the different kinds of data that an MFI can collect, who needs access to the data and for what purposes, and how to store and manage your data so that it is accessible and usable for the whole organization.

Design an excellent intake form: The guide emphasizes the importance of intake forms for establishing baseline measurements, and provides an some straight-forward but important recommendations for making your intake form usable. It recommends keeping your intake form short, making it precise and making sure the questions asked of the client are clear and well defined.

Mapping Outcomes: Data that works goes on to emphasize the importance of tracking your program’s outcomes in terms of your organization’s mission, the performance of the organization and, importantly, the success of your clients.  It offers an easy to use format for doing so.

Using data effectively: Tracking outcomes is interesting, but ineffective until that data is applied towards making a program run better or a product more useful to your clients. Data that works concludes its recommendations with a discussion of the various ways a data-driven organization can outperform less data-responsive organizations.

In combination, these guides offer a powerful starting place for both student groups and startup MFIs working to design an effective microfinance program. Be sure to integrate them into your resource library!

Weekly Microfinance News & Announcements 2/3/2012

Posted: 2012-02-03 @ 6:00 AM EST

Think Again: Microfinance

By David Roodman, Foreign Policy What has made so many so sure of microcredit? The ideas are powerful: a blend of self-reliance and liberation that appeals across the political spectrum.

How “the crisis” changed microfinance and where we go from here…

By Sam Mendelson, Microfinance Focus A little over a year ago, this industry of ours was shaken to its core. It wasn’t so much the events in Andhra Pradesh (AP) per se – distressing as some stories of client mistreatment were.

Revive Made in USA? Easier said than done

By Parija Kavilanz, CNN “We didn’t pay that with a small business loan,” she said. “That came from our savings.” Still, she’s not bitter. Her factory has created 50 new jobs in the area. And she hopes to grow that to 100 this year. “We’re trying to do the right thing and …

The true costs of prepaid debit cards

By Felix Salmon, Reuters Blogs (blog) By Felix Salmon Anisha Sekar of Nerdwallet has officially launched a comparison tool which allows you to work out which prepaid debit card might be best for you — and, crucially, allows you to compare the cost of a prepaid debit card to the cost of a …

900+ Have Already Signed WeFunder Petition Demanding Crowdfunding of Startups

By Walter Frick, BostInno While “crowdfunding” has been a success in charitable contexts with sites like Kiva and Kickstarter, as the law currently stands startups are able to take money only from accredited investors, and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) limits the …

What Will It Take To Save the Unbanked?

By Justine Rivero , Forbes Controversy surrounding celebrity-endorsed prepaid cards threw around words like “unbanked” and “underbanked.” But the real head-scratcher isn’t the high-fee cards and their Hollywood affiliations, but why it’s taken so long to recognize the plight of …

Big Banks’ Small Business Lending: Do The Numbers Really Add Up?

By Janean Chun, The Huffington Post News Editors But Kassar has crunched the data the four banks reported for the quarterly FDIC call reports and found that these banks did not show increases in outstanding small-business loan balances from the end of 2010 to the third quarter of 2011.

How Nonprofits And Commercial Groups Can Help The Economy

By Lewis Humphries, San Francisco Chronicle As if to prove how valuable and effective these unions can be, the Create Jobs for USA campaign enjoyed instant success in gaining funds to both create and …

A New Era Under The Volcker Rule

By Matt Atkins, Financier Worldwide Due for implementation in July 2012, the Volcker Rule, part the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform Act, aims to reduce the scope for banks to make risky investments with their own capital. Current proposals will ban banks from making trades from their own …

Microlinks Posts Recap of Roodman/Bateman Debate

Posted: 2012-02-01 @ 6:02 PM EST

Microlinks has posted a thorough recap of Monday’s Moving Financial Inclusion beyond Microfinance debate between David Roodman and Milford Bateman on their blog. The recap carefully reconstructs the flow of this parliamentary style debate and gives a balanced overview of the most important points discussed by Milford and Bateman.  Be sure to check out the link to the debate notes, and to David Roodman’s post-debate blog entry which includes a rebuttal from Bateman in the comments section.  Also, be sure to check out the Executive Summary of the much-contested Inter-American Development Bank report The Age of Productivity which has been the subject of intense disagreement between Bateman and Roodman.

David Roodman and Milford Bateman Debate Recap

Posted: 2012-01-30 @ 4:58 PM EST

UPDATE: Check out the microlinks post-event resource page for a recording of the debate, a transcript and more!

On Monday January 30th USAID and the Financial Inclusion Forum of D.C. hosted a much anticipated parliamentary style debate between David Roodman, Author of Due Dilligence: An Impertinent Inquiry into Microfinance, and Milford Bateman, author of Why Doesn’t microfinance Work: The Destructive Rise of Local Neoliberalism. The debate was entitled “Moving Financial Inclusion Beyond Microfinance” and the central question was:

“If microfinance has not achieved its objective in substantially reducing poverty, what are the pathways to financial inclusion that will contribute to this objective?”

The debate was moderated by Chuck Waterfield of MFTransparency. To find out more about the context for the debate see this exchange between Roodman and Bateman in the comments section of David Roodman’s Microfinance Open Book Blog.

David Roodman won the coin toss and started out the parliamentary-style debate by laying out his top ten reasons for why it is incorrect to characterize microfinance as a completely useless tool in poverty alleviation work. Amongst his reasons, he noted the tendency in microfinance literature to exaggerate both positive and negative impacts, and argued instead for deemphasizing the most extreme viewpoints for the sake of developing a more evidence-based discourse. He preempted the question of opportunity costs and the accusation by some (including Bateman) that microfinance is diverting resources away from other interventions to the detriment of economic development in some regions. Roodman noted that the data on this question is weak, and that it is both difficult and speculative to prove that microfinance is diverting resources away from more effective or impactful economic development interventions to the detriment of local economies. He cited the randomized control trials on the impact of microfinance that have shown the overall average impact of microfinance to be zero, and in some cases to be slightly positive. Even so, Roodman contends that microfinance comprises a market which needs to be regulated like any other. He emphasized that the term microfinance does not exclusively apply to microcredit, but that it also includes savings, insurance and mobile money transfer solutions which deserve their own evaluation criteria. He refuted Bateman’s suggestion that microfinance does not have a place in the broader vision of industrialization and asserted that there are many innovations in microfinance which deserve critical inquiry and consideration.

Bateman countered by clarifying that he does not argue that there are no benefits to microfinance, but that the evidence indicates that the costs do clearly outweigh the benefits. He also makes the distinction that his critique is limited to microcredit, and that he too feels there is potential in micro savings, insurance and other microfinance tools. He characterizes microcredit as having become corrupted by commercialism, such that the poor are expected to finance their own way out of poverty. He went on to accuse the microfinance community of resisting evidence that demonstrates the negative impacts of microfinance. He interprets this resistance as self-serving, and he suggests that the move by many MFIs towards a financial inclusion paradigm is a way of justifying their own existence in the face of this negative evidence. Milford rebuked Roodman’s assertion that there is no place for extremes in this dialogue, and claimed that in fact it is possible that there is truth in the extremes. Bateman accused Roodman of interpreting the success of the microfinance industry itself as evidence of its own positive impact, and argues instead that we should be seeking evidence for impact in poverty indicators. He advocates for moving resources and inquiry into more locally based solutions to economic development like credit unions, local banks, enterprise development efforts and cash grants and away from microcredit.

The debate was followed by a lively question and answer session.

Roodman, Bateman Debate Monday January 30th

Posted: 2012-01-27 @ 8:30 AM EST

Don’t miss David Roodman and Milford Bateman’s debate on Monday, January 30th!

Presenters:

David Roodman, Center for Global Development

Milford Bateman, University of Juraj Dobrila of Pula

Chuck Waterfield (moderator), MFTransparency

Winning Debate Question:

If microfinance has not achieved its objective in substantially reducing poverty, what are the pathways to financial inclusion that will contribute to this objective?

Event details:

Date: Monday, January 30th

Time: 9:00am to 11:00am EST

How to register: Click here to register to watch the webcast of the debate

More information: Click here to read an pre-debate exchange between Roodman and Milford on David Roodman’s Microfinance Open Book Blog

Stay tuned for a recap of the debate on the Microfinance USA Conference blog.

Weekly Microfinance News & Announcements 1/27/2012

Posted: 2012-01-27 @ 6:00 AM EST

Microfinance: A Help or Hindrance to the Poor?

By Morgan Wharton, PolicyMic While these situations represent legitimate fears associated with the social contract that microfinance clients must adhere to, they should not be sufficient enough to deter potential clients from accepting microcredit. Roodman also criticizes the …

Debate: Moving Financial Inclusion Beyond Microfinance

By Microlinks If microfinance has not achieved its objective in substantially reducing poverty, what are the pathways to financial inclusion that will contribute to this objective?

Share the Wealth: ‘Bank On Baton Rouge’ opens doors for needy individuals

By Jay Meyers, LSU That world is a reality for one in four people living in Baton Rouge who are either unbanked or underbanked, meaning they don’t use a bank or credit union …

First National Bank to Offer Mobile Wallet Solution to Unbanked

By Bryan Yurcan, Banktech South Africa’s First National Bank is partnering with retailer Pep to offer its mobile wallet device to the unbanked and underbanked.

Combining microfinance and health

By Microfinance Focus Microcredit Summit Campaign and Freedom from Hunger have joined hands to reach more than 700000 microfinance clients with health education and services over the next five years. The goal of the alliance is to work …

Muhammad Yunus – A History of Microfinance | TEDxVienna

By Vlad Gozman, TEDxVienna … University where he developed the concepts of microcredit and microfinance. He is the author of Banker to the Poor and two books on Social Business Models, and a founding board member of Grameen America and Grameen Foundation.

Grameen’s business empire

By The Economist Muhammad Yunus, winner of the 2006 Nobel peace prize, founded Grameen Bank in 1983 to provide tiny loans to poor rural women. Grameen became a global model for microfinance. It also spawned 48 other firms in sectors that stretch from textiles to mobile …

Peer to peer lending: the murky future with America’s new consumer protector

By Alex Lee, Reuters Blogs (blog) By way of background, peer to peer (P2P) lending microcredit institutions sprang up in 2005 in order to provide needy borrowers with viable alternatives to normal commercial bank loans. This industry had as its backbone, the seemingly novel concept of …

Weekly Microfinance News & Announcements 1/20/2012

Posted: 2012-01-20 @ 6:00 AM EST

What’s an Entrepreneur? The Best Answer Ever

By Eric Schurenberg, Inc.com As an entrepreneur, you surely have an elevator pitch, the pithy 15-second synopsis of what your company does and why, and you can all but repeat it in your sleep. But until recently, I’d never seen a good elevator pitch for entrepreneurship itself—that is, what you do that all entrepreneurs do?

Kiva’s Secret Project To Let You Give Peer-To-Peer Loans | SOCAP

By SOCAP Blog But many lenders assumed–not surprisingly, given Kiva’s marketing and web design–that the smiling face on the other end of the PayPal transaction got the exact cash they lent out. A minor kerfuffle ensued in 2009 when a blogger broadcast …

Social impact is an integral part of investors agenda – Microfinance Focus

By Microfinance Focus Bob Annibale speaks about the vision of Citi Microfinance for the global microfinance sector. … There also are significant unbanked and underserved communities in the United States and we have some very interesting partners and initiatives there too, particularly for savings and asset building. At Citi, we continually look for innovative solutions to tailor our existing products to our wide variety of clients and partner MFIs and to specialized banks, microfinance funds and donors. Mobile …

Banorte targets Mexico’s underbanked with mobile-based service

By Finextra … has teamed with payments specialist Rev Worldwide to launch a mobile-based financial services programme aimed at the country’s millions of underbanked. …

Obama to Elevate SBA Chief

By Emily Maltby, The Wall Street Journal President Barack Obama said Friday that he will exercise his executive authority to elevate the head of the U.S. Small Business Administration to a cabinet-level position.

ZestCash Closes $73 Million in Funding

by Juan Carols Perez, PCWorld Traditional “payday” lenders offer small, short-term loans to borrowers who are known as underbanked, because they can’t get loans from banks and other ..

Microfinance Jobs Roundup

Posted: 2012-01-17 @ 9:43 AM EST

Interested in finding a job in microfinance in your community? Check out this roundup of job opportunities from microfinance organizations around the country. Click on the states below to see job listings.

Alabama
Arizona
California
Colorado
Illinois
Louisiana
Massachusetts
New Mexico
Texas

Alabama

ACCION Texas, Loan Officer, Alabama

Arizona

ACCION New Mexico, Colorado, Arizona Loan Officer

California

ACCION San Diego, Loan Officer

Opportunity Fund, Reporting and Compliance Officer, San Francisco Bay Area

Opportunity Fund, Small Business Loan Consultant/Outside Sales, San Francisco Bay Area

KIVA, Chief Financial Officer, San Francisco

KIVA, Associate Project Manager Consumer Applications, San Francisco

KIVA, Systems Administrator, San Francisco

KIVA, Software Developer, San Francisco

KIVA, Software Engineer-General, San Francisco

KIVA, Portfolio Manager, Strategic Initiatives, San Francisco

Colorado

ACCION New Mexico, Colorado, Arizona Loan Officer

Illinois

ACCION Chicago, Accounting Associate, Chicago

ACCION Chicago, Loan Officer, Chicago

Louisiana

ACCION Texas, Loan Officer, Alexandria, Baton Rouge, New Orleans, Shreveport

ACCION Texas, Loan Processor, Alexandria, Baton Rouge, New Orleans, Shreveport

Massachusetts

ACCION USA Network, Bilingual Loan Operations Associate, Boston

New Mexico

ACCION New Mexico, Colorado, Arizona Loan Officer

ACCION New Mexico, Colorado, Arizona Bilingual Office Administrator, Albuquerque

Texas

ACCION Texas, Business Financial Advisor, San Antonio

ACCION Texas, Business Advisor, Dallas, Houston

ACCION Texas, Trainer

ACCION Texas, Loan Underwriter

ACCION Texas, Capital Resources Director, San Antonio

ACCION Texas, Loan Officer Northwest Texas Region

ACCION Texas, Loan Officer, Austin, Brownsville, Corpus Christi, Dallas, Fort Worth, El Paso, Houston, Laredo, McAllen, San Antonio

ACCION Texas, Loan Processor, Austin, Brownsville, Corpus Christi, Dallas, Fort Worth, El Paso, Houston, Laredo, McAllen, San Antonio

ACCION Texas Customer Service Loan Processor, San Antonio